Vol.4 Ch.25 – Returning The Favor

Chapter 25: Returning The Favor

Alexis didn't really lose consciousness, nothing so dramatic. But after having an earth-shattering orgasm from the toy spreading her ass open there were a few minutes where she couldn't have moved if the room had caught on fire, her eyes and ears and limbs all filled with white noise.

When the haze around her cleared she found herself in Cassie's lap, sort of. He had crossed his legs before placing her head on his thigh and it only occurred to her after a little while that he'd done that so his erection wouldn't touch her, which she found both thoughtful and oddly touching, though she was so zonked out that she probably wouldn't even have noticed it poking her.

Either way she was lying on his lap, his hands idly running through her hair while he made soothing noises. It was a really comforting moment, though it would be much more relaxing if he didn't feel like he had to walk on eggshells around her. She could feel it clearly now. He was tense, every muscle in his body tensed up, careful to keep himself in just the right pose. She hated it.

She knew it was her fault, knew he was doing this to not have her feel uncomfortable, knew he was probably right to do it, that she might actually freak if he'd been acting like a guy all this time, but still she didn't want him to feel uncomfortable. It was his room, he was helping her. And yet not only was he sitting here wire-taut, he was also hiding an erection while she was basking in the afterglow of a mind-shattering orgasm. The very least she should do would be to leave him alone so he could take care of himself. However, the proper thing to do would be to help him.

She'd spent her fair share of time listening to girl talk among her friends back in high school and so she was pretty sure most of the girls she'd known back then would have offered Cassie a blowjob in her situation.

She didn't really feel comfortable with that idea. Not because it would feel like cheating – they were in the same relationship after all – but because it would be sucking a dick attached to someone other than Elaine. She wasn't ready for that, wasn't sure if she would ever be ready for that. Jerking him off, maybe, possibly, but not that. Nope. But then again, given what Cassie had actually been helping her with she was pretty sure there would be something he'd prefer.

“Thank you,” she said.

“No problem,” he said gently.

“Want me to return the favor?” she asked.

“You don't have to,” he said, clearly not wanting to freak her out.

“I want to,” she said, and meant it.

**

Evelyn had never really gone for muscular partners. It had usually been the lean and fit guys, not built and bulky types. And while they'd all been stronger than her waifish old self, she'd never really had a partner who could just pick her up and carry her. Until now.

After cumming down Evelyn's throat and triggering a world-shattering orgasm in her Elaine had picked her up and placed her on the bed. And those strong, muscular arms wrapping around her and hauling her around with zero effort while she was still shaking from her orgasm was one of the hottest things Evelyn had ever experienced. She loved being manhandled by Elaine, loved the interplay between knowing her partner was strong enough to keep her safe and sheltered and knowing her partner could tie her into knots. It would be the stuff abusive relationships were made out of if Elaine wasn't so unflinchingly loving and careful around her.

Evelyn could barely move her body, was too weak to speak up and because of the choker she'd been unable to wear her CARD. But still she wanted more, needed more. She needed Elaine to not give her a chance to rest. She needed Elaine to drive her insane. And so she drew together what little strength she had and spread her legs for Elaine, then reached down with both hands to spread her labia.

For a moment she was worried Elaine wouldn't notice it but then she felt her girlfriend shifting on the bed, her breathing growing heavier.

**

Okay, I get it now, Alexis thought as Cassie rolled over for her.

He was on his stomach, his legs off the bed and his bare ass on full display. And he was gorgeous.

For reasons that eluded her Cassie had an hourglass figure almost more pronounced than her own, his waist slim, his hips wide and his chest wider than a guy's should be. His shoulders were just that tiny little bit too broad to pass as female but not enough for it to be distracting. His blond braid draped over his back looked more luxurious and well cared for than her own hair, his skin as silky smooth as the girly girls she'd fantasized about dating before she'd met Elaine, and his ass. Dear Lord, that ass.

She'd complimented him earlier, mostly because his compliment had caught her off-guard, but she'd meant it. Cassie had an ass a lot of women would kill for. She was absolutely certain of her attraction to the fairer sex and she wanted to eat whipped cream off that ass, not despite her preferences but because of them. His ass was so round and soft and jiggly that even the dick dangling beneath it couldn't make it look less feminine. That talk of his shoulders being too broad? Irrelevant the moment you saw that ass. She could totally see what Elaine saw in him.

What was less obvious to her was the toy he'd handed her. It looked just as unnatural as the one he'd abused her ass with, at least to her. The thing was long, a bit longer even than Elaine's, and it had some weight to it. The tip wasn't a tip at all, instead it was flat, with a wide flare around it, and about halfway down its length there was a prominent ring-shaped wedge, beyond which it grew slightly wider, and at its base the dildo had a pair of large, round balls.

She knew, objectively, that if Cassie had taken Elaine's cock that this thing would probably fit but still, she couldn't imagine herself fitting something like this, ever, in any hole.

But regardless, no matter how ready Cassie said he was she still didn't think he'd be able to take this without foreplay so she started by putting some lube on her fingers, intending to massage it into his hole.

As she reached out he reached back to spread his cheeks for her.

God, does mine look like this?

Cassie's ass looked obscene to her. She didn't know if that's just what buttholes looked like – she wasn't in the habit of looking at naked people online – but something about the sight was almost too raunchy for her. The wrinkled ring of flesh looked puffy, almost engorged like a pair of pussy lips, and it wasn't the perfect circle like she thought it would be. It had more of an oblong shape, the ring more of an oval. And the thought of sticking her fingers in there aroused her to no end.

She touched her lubed fingers to his flesh and he felt feverishly hot to the touch, even through the cold lube. Given how she'd hissed when the lube had first touched her she didn't worry when he sucked in a breath at the first touch, especially when he relaxed right after.

His explanations about needing foreplay for the ass to relax enough to open up were still fresh in her mind and so when his asshole opened up after the slightest bit of prodding she knew he was either way more used to this than she ever would be or he'd already been playing with it earlier today.

Either way she slowly slid first one finger inside him, then a second.

“You feel really nice inside,” she said, surprising herself with the words.

“Your fingers feel great, too,” he said, his voice already somewhat strained. It no longer sounded like he was tense, more like he was already feeling it from just this. “You can add a third if you want.”

“Sure,” she said, then slid a third finger inside him to his moans. It felt tight, though not too tight. She asked: “Another?”

“Yes please.”

And she obliged.

**

Elaine could barely handle how sexy her girlfriend was. Showing up wearing nothing but a trench coat and a choker that asked for a throat fuck? Amazing. Actually getting on her knees and taking it down her throat like a good girl? Even better. The choker ripping from the force of Elaine's orgasm blasting down her throat? Unbelievably sexy. Coming from having Elaine's cum pumped directly into her stomach? Incredible. Spreading herself open for Elaine to fuck while basking in the afterglow of an orgasm? Perfect.

Evelyn clearly couldn't speak right now, still mostly incoherent, but the way she'd spread her legs and labia was a signal so obvious that Elaine wouldn't miss even at her most obtuse: “Fuck me while I'm blissed out, I want to go insane.”

Elaine was happy enough to provide that for her.

She slid in between Evelyn's thighs, her cock already raring to go again, and simply shoved herself inside the redhead. Instinctively Evelyn spread her legs a little wider still to accommodate Elaine's girth and soon Elaine was balls deep inside her.

If Evelyn's mouth felt like home, her pussy felt even better. Amazingly tight, though less so right now with how relaxed her entire body had gotten from the orgasm, swelteringly hot, soaking wet and able to take her entire length with no room to spare. And then there were the sounds. It wasn't just the filthy squelching sounds driving Elaine crazy, it was also the groans and grunts and gasps Evelyn let out at the way she was being fucked, sounding not so much like sex as it sounded like a religious experience the girl was having. It fit with the way Evelyn acted around her. Evelyn didn't just love her, she worshiped her, in the best way possible. And Elaine loved the treatment. She would do everything in her power to be deserving of that worship. And so she gave Evelyn exactly what she needed.

She reached down and grabbed hold of Evelyn's sweet tits, just big enough to fit comfortably in her hands without being overly impressive, and gave them a squeeze, rough but not too rough. And with her cock firmly buried inside her and two handfuls of boob she leaned down and put the most passionate liplock on the girl she knew how to do.

**

Cassie's brain had short-circuited when Alexis had offered to return the favor and so, completely forgetting that he'd been trying not to freak her out, he'd handed her the toy he'd wanted inside him instead of a tamer one he wouldn't mind her seeing. From her dubious but not disgusted look he could tell she didn't know what kind of dildo he'd handed her but, in his defense, he hadn't bought the thing because it was a horse dildo but just because he'd been curious how it would feel. And it felt amazing. It used to make him sore for days but it was worth it. Or rather, it had been worth it until he'd met Elaine. Now it didn't really do it for him anymore but it was the best he had.

Or at least he'd thought so until he'd felt Alexis' fingers on his hole. They felt amazing, small and dainty, definitely too small to fill him up but... Fuck, would she be game for that? Well, she had offered to help him out of her own volition so... it wouldn't hurt to ask, would it?