Chapter 63: Menage a Trois

A/N: Here's the new Chapter! Which also means the next four chapters are up on my for early access as well as the chance to vote on the direction of the story!

Thalia thinks she knows exactly what she's doing. She does not.

-x-X-x-

Well, if Annabeth didn’t look so judgy, maybe Thalia would have had the presence of mind to calm her libido and stop the sexy times there and then. After all, she’d gotten what she wanted. She certainly wasn’t a virgin anymore.

… But Thalia had never been good with authority figures trying to tell her what to do. And while Annabeth had yet to say the word, she gave off the air of someone who was exasperated with Thalia’s antics and that… that had Thalia’s hackles raising. If she backed down now, if she ended things here, then Annabeth might take it to imply some level of shame or regret on Thalia’s part. And that just couldn’t be further from the truth.

That meant she needed to keep going, and that probably meant she needed to chase Annabeth away. But what would be the best way to send the judgmental Daughter of Athena running for the hills? Being blunt and telling Annabeth to get out was one option, but it didn’t feel like a very good one. Annabeth wasn’t likely to respond very well to such dismissal. However, if she went the opposite direction… yeah, that could work.

Arching her back and plastering a wide and wicked grin on her face, Thalia gyrates her hips all over Percy’s cock, undulating rather seductively if she says so herself as she maintains direct eye contact with Annabeth.

“Anna~ Care to join us?”

As expected, Thalia’s impromptu offer of a threesome causes Annabeth to freeze in place, her eyes widening in disbelief. The plan was working perfectly. Any moment now the blonde’s face would go bright red in sheer embarrassment and she would be forced to flee the room in the face of Thalia’s brazen question.

… Any moment now.

Except, that’s not what happens. Instead, Annabeth gets over her surprise in record time and stomps over to the bed. It’s Thalia’s turn for her eyes to widen in disbelief as the Daughter of Athena comes to a stop at the side of the bed and then climbs up onto it. What the hell was Annabeth-mmph?!

Cut off mid-thought, Thalia finds herself suddenly being kissed… and kissed aggressively. The other female demigod has a hand in Thalia’s short black locks and is going to town on her mouth before Thalia can even register what’s happening. Annabeth’s tongue pushes past Thalia’s lips and is soon wrestling with her tongue, even as Thalia lets out a muffled moan of confusion.

Confusion… but not distress. Annabeth is NOT a bad kisser, and in fact, Thalia quite enjoys the impromptu makeout session with the other woman. Indeed, she finds herself leaning into Annabeth more and more, her pussy walls flexing unconsciously around the big fat cock still buried inside of her as they continue to kiss. Until suddenly, they’re not.

Thalia blinks stupidly, in a bit of a daze for a moment as Annabeth suddenly leaves her. By the time she finally gets ahold of herself a few seconds later, it’s to look down and find Annabeth has all but draped herself over Percy and is kissing the ever-living fuck out of him as well.

Blushing, Thalia’s inner walls clench around the male demigod’s cock again at the sight. Why was seeing Annabeth and Percy making out in front of her so damn hot? She honestly couldn’t say. But it really was… almost as hot as kissing Annabeth herself had been.

Finally, the two have to pull apart for air. Sitting up, Annabeth begins removing her clothes while at the same time giving Thalia an exasperated yet fond look.

“You know Thalia, next time you wake up and decide to jump the first man you see, you might want to ask if he’s single first.”

Wait, what? Thalia’s pussy walls clench around Percy’s cock again, but this time it’s more out of fear than arousal. Did Annabeth mean what she thought she meant…?

Shucking her top over her head, Annabeth chuckles at the poleaxed look on Thalia’s face as she reaches back to remove her bra next.

“You’re lucky that I’ve already learned to share Percy here with multiple other women. I’m even happy about it, because he’s a bit too much to handle on my own. I leave him alone for a week and he’s mind breaking goddesses left and right with that big fat cock of his.”

Huh?!

Annabeth’s breasts, smaller than Thalia’s but not by much, bounce free of their confines once she removes her bra, making it even harder for Thalia to process the bombshells Annabeth keeps dropping on her. Then, Annabeth goes to remove her pants and panties as well.

“Said cock better be free by the time I’m done stripping by the way, or I really am going to be angry with you, Thalia~”

Squeaking at the actually intimidating tone Annabeth somehow pulls out of her ass, Thalia finds herself getting off of Percy’s cock in a hurry. Though she’s not willing to completely back off… even as she kneels on the other side of the male demigod, she wraps a hand around his dick, stroking it and… almost laying claim to it in a way. Except apparently this was a phallus that had already been laid claim to by multiple other women… including a fucking goddess?!

“I know what you’re thinking, Thalia. You’re thinking “A goddess?! Seriously?!” but no. Not just a goddess. Multiple goddesses.”

Thalia’s jaw drops open as Annabeth snorts derisively and finally naked, moves into the position that the Daughter of Zeus has left behind. Climbing aboard, the beautiful blonde demigod wastes no time in impaling herself on Percy’s cock, Thalia’s hand inadvertently providing the stabilization that Annabeth needs as she descends his member right then and there.

Once she’s got him inside of her to the hilt, Annabeth reaches down and caresses Percy’s cheek for a moment. Then, she looks to Thalia and reaches out, grabbing her roughly by the hair once more.

“Bitch.”

There’s a fondness in her tone and relief in her voice that softens the word. As well, when Annabeth follows it up by kissing Thalia fully on the lips, it makes it clear she meant it more as a term of endearment than anything else. Thalia moans as she kisses Annabeth again, this time on the side as Annabeth rides Percy harder and faster by the moment. To think, she’d thought she’d got quite the catch… but in actuality, she’d lost her virginity to the Camp’s bicycle from what Annabeth was saying.

Then again, if they were going with that analogy, considering Percy had bagged not one but multiple goddesses, that made him more of a top of the line motorcycle than anything else, didn’t it? But at a certain point, they were stretching the metaphor to the breaking point.

Finally pulling back for air, Annabeth gives Thalia a broad smile.

“I’m glad… your back, Thalia.”

Thalia perks up at that. She can tell the sentiment is heartfelt, even if it’s slightly broken up by Annabeth’s breath hitching as she bounces up and down on her apparent lover’s cock. Grinning slightly, the Daughter of Zeus chuckles.

“Glad to be back, Anna. Guessing we’ve got a lot to catch me up on, yeah?”

At that, the smile diminishes slightly and Annabeth sighs.

“… Yeah. But we’ll talk about that after, okay?”

Thalia hums and nods. From the sound of things, it wasn’t all sunshine and roses. But they could get her up to speed later. For now… she was WAY too fucking horny to be content with just one round! And while she wasn’t going to force Annabeth off of Percy just so she could have another ride, Thalia was more than willing to try and speed things along a little bit. Namely by slipping into place behind Annabeth and wrapping her hands around the other woman’s body to begin groping her tits as she nibbles at her neck.

“A-Ah! Thalia!”

Giggling, Thalia doesn’t let up for even a second… and neither does Percy as he thrusts up into Annabeth from below. Together, the two of them turn the beautiful genius of a blonde into a moaning, mewling mess of a woman. And then they do a lot of other fun stuff together as well~

-x-X-x-

“… Huh.”

Percy exchanges a look with Annabeth at that. After all was said and done, the three of them had wound up taking a shower together. Then, toweled off and dressed, they’d sat Thalia down and got her up to speed on everything that had happened while she was inside of that pine tree. This included Zeus’ death and Luke’s betrayal as the biggest things, but also everything else as well.

In response, Thalia’s reaction had been… decidedly underwhelming. Was that normal for her? Judging by how Annabeth looked a bit nonplussed, Percy didn’t think it was. Indeed, Annabeth’s brow furrows and she huffs as she crosses her arms over her chest.

“’Huh’? We just dropped years’ worth of a proverbial shit storm on your head and all you can say is ‘huh’?”

Thalia tilts her head to the side, humming for a moment in consideration.

“I think… I’m most upset about Luke. He and I saw each other through some serious bullshit. Survived some really bad situations even before we met you Anna. He saved my life the very first time we met, and I saved his life a few times too. So… kind of sucks that he apparently poisoned my tree I guess.”

Shrugging, Thalia sighs.

“The rest of it is a little harder for me to care about if I’m being honest. Camp Half-Blood was always the goal, but unlike you guys I didn’t make it there. So I can’t really say I’m overly attached to it. And Zeus… well, talk about deadbeat dads. I don’t know if I hate him like Luke apparently hates the gods, but I also don’t really care that he’s dead? It sounds like he kind of fucked around and found out anyways…”

Here, Thalia gets a more pondering look on her face.

“Still, probably bad if grandpa comes back, isn’t it? Especially if we just got something approaching democracy over on Mount Olympus. Better that then letting another tyrant usurp control, yeah?”

Yes. That was the incredibly simplified version of things, but still yes. Percy was starting to get a better idea of Thalia’s personality from this conversation, truth be told. Honestly, he’d gotten a full frontal blast of the beautiful raven-haired tomboy’s personality back when she’d woken up and immediately jumped his bones. He probably should have put a stop to that before anything had actually happened, but Thalia hadn’t really given him much room to talk her down and he hadn’t wanted to reject her out of hand.

… Ah hell, who was he kidding? She was super fucking hot too, and he’d rather enjoyed fucking her. Fortunately, Annabeth was more than understanding about things. But then, she had to be when she was just one of many women that shared Percy’s bed at this point in time.

“Frankly, the most interesting bit of information in all of this is that I lost my virginity to a would-be god.”

Thalia gives him a grin at that, causing Percy to chuckle sheepishly.

“I’m not anywhere close to that yet, I don’t think. Still a demigod, just like the both of you.”

Thalia hums, sounding unconvinced as she eyes him up and down.

“I dunno… there was definitely something positively divine about that dick of yours. Especially when you pushed me face down into the bed and railed me from behind like-!”

“Pause the flirting, please. We can fuck some more later, but it’d probably be best to make a showing at dinner time at the very least now that you’re awake, Thalia.”

Annabeth’s words of reason provoke stomach growls from both Thalia AND Percy as it so happens, causing both demigods to blush a little bit as they realize how long it’s been since they ate. For Percy, all he did was skip lunch. But for Thalia… well, it’s been years hasn’t it?

“I was just coming to relieve Percy from his shift when I got pulled into everything. The next relief isn’t do for another thirty minutes, but we’ve officially used up all of our time. So I say we head on down, introduce you to everyone else, and get some grub. What do you think?”

Thalia gives him one last considering look, as though she’s really considering whether her ‘hunger’ eclipses her literal hunger or not. Finally though, she sighs and nods.

“Alright, fine. Let’s go.”

With that, the three of them begin to make their way out of the Big House, Annabeth and Thalia side by side and continuing to catch up with one another. Percy doesn’t mind being the odd one out of the trio. If Luke weren’t such a dick bag, it should have been him in Percy’s place. Not necessarily for the sex parts mind you, but simply to help Thalia acclimate to the world she’d been absent from for all these years.

Instead, Luke was off doing who the fuck knew what for that bastard Titan of Time. Percy regretted missing out on giving the Son of Hermes a piece of his mind, but from what Annabeth had told him, it was only because they were both women that Circe had been so willing to help her and Clarisse on their quest. And without a Goddess of Magic’s power backing them, who knows what would have happened when Luke came for them after they retrieved the Golden Fleece?

In the end, it was for the best that Percy had stayed behind. All was well that ended well. Thalia was back and Annabeth was happy. Whatever came next, at least they’d saved Camp Half-Blood.

Realizing he’s gotten lost in his own thoughts for a second, Percy blinks and looks up, ready to catch up with the girls and head to dinner. He was, after all, starving.

[ ] He finds himself making it to dinner with Thalia and Annabeth without issue, Circe isn't ready yet - 30%

If you'd like to read more of my work not seen on this website, check out Hentai-Foundry.com and QuestionableQuesting.com where I have over a thousand stories!

If you'd like to contribute to funding my writing at all, check me out on .com/Cambrian

Thanks for reading!