Vol.3 Ch.6 – Making Up For Lost Time

Chapter 6: Making Up For Lost Time

I beheld the tableau of naked, blushing beauties before me. Yume was still down for the count, panting and twitching on the bed, breathing like a bellows and looking at me through lidded eyes. At the same time Selene and Alisha were looking at me expectantly, each with a hand between their thighs, rubbing gentle circles as they hoped to be next, and I considered who to choose.

Alisha had done something really rather filthy for me and deserved a reward for it but her and I'd had fun on the trip here while Selene had been holding it in ever since we set out on this journey. They both deserved to go first but in the end what decided it was that Alisha loved the feeling of being left needy and unfulfilled while I took care of the others.

Thus decided I reached out and grabbed Selene's hips before pulling her towards me and burying my face between her legs. I still needed a few minutes to recover before I could give her the fucking she truly deserved and in any case it had been a while since I'd last gone down on her.

The moment my mouth touched her lower lips she gasped and wrapped her legs around me, squeezing tightly but not too tightly. Gods above but I would never get enough of this. Her thighs were toned and yet still surprisingly plush, softness covering hard muscle, her skin silky smooth despite her being a hardened warriors. The scar tissue crisscrossing her limbs added a fascinating contrast, thin lines of her skin being rougher and slightly cooler than the hot velvet of the rest of her. And gods above, her pussy.

She tasted sweet, of roses and sage, her pussy dripping with arousal and her flesh quivering underneath my lips and tongue.

“No fair," I heard Alisha whine a moment before she cooed and the bed shifted beside Selene and me.

I glanced up to see Alisha lying on her back, Yume on top of her, working her slender fingers in and out of the little elf, who rolled her hips against her touch. Selene's gaze was torn between me and the two of them, her eyes hazy with lust as she massaged her own breasts.

I gave her clit a playful nibble to draw her attention back to me before I slipped two fingers inside my lovely warrior. Instantly her insides squeezed down on me, clutching my fingers, desperate to be filled.

“You always feel so amazing inside," I muttered before I started peppering her flesh with feather-light kisses as I worked my fingers in and out of her. “So tight and needy...”

“I'm sure it would feel even better wrapped around your cock," she told me, her voice coming out as a squeaky gasp.

“Patience," I rumbled as I sucked one of her lower lips into my mouth, massaging it with my lips and giving it a few gentle licks before letting go. At the same time I curled my finger up to work that special spot inside her, easily finding the bumpy spot I was looking for, and she bucked her hips off the bed. I smirked at her reaction, then began fucking my fingers against the spot in a steady rhythm.

“Gods above," she gasped, thrusting her hips in time with my strokes, bucking against the air.

I was so caught up in making her writhe and twist on the bed, her face scrunched up in pleasure, that it took me a while to notice that I was already hard again, my erection pressing almost painfully into the mattress.

And so I kept teasing her, more and more, bringing her to the brink of orgasm. We'd been together for several months now and I knew Selene's body in and out, knew exactly what she liked and how much she could take. And I used it to play her body like a fiddle, making her teeter on the edge only to yank her back again and again until she was begging and pleading with me to let her come.

“Please... please... I need it...” she whined, her voice almost a sob she was so desperate.

“Yeah?” I asked, pulling my fingers out of her. “Then flip around.”

She complied without even a hint of hesitation, flipping onto her stomach and presenting herself for me, putting herself on display in the hopes of getting her release faster.

I gave her ass a single smack and kept my hand there, grabbing and kneading her cheek as I spread her apart. She was beet-red and soaking wet, as needy as I'd ever seen her, and I lined my cock up at her entrance, then pushed inside her with excruciating slowness.

“Ohgodohgodohgodohgod," she chanted as I forced her soaking wet hole open with my cock.

Once I was halfway inside I slipped a thumb, slick with her juices, into her tight little pucker as well, filling her from both sides.

“Mrrrrthrrrfrrrckrrr," she grumbled into the pillow and her pussy clamped down on my cock, her insides seizing up and quivering from an intense orgasm.

She felt so amazing inside I had to pause in my tracks, dangerously close to cumming already, but when her insides finally relaxed I pulled out of her, dragging my cock out of her pussy as slowly as I could manage until only the tip was left inside her. As her breathing slowly evened back out I worked my finger in and out of her ass, pulling out on each inhale and pushing back in on each exhale, and when she had calmed back down again I shoved my cock back inside her in one deep, savage thrust, then began to give her the fucking she truly needed, the fucking she deserved.

“Yeshh...” I heard a gargled moan as I plowed into Selene and it took me a moment to realize that it hadn't been the paladin who had made the sound.

Next to us Alisha was writhing on the bed, three of the little fox's fingers working in and out of her pussy and another three plunging into her mouth over and over again. As I watched Yume switched hands, feeding the fingers covered in pussy juice into Alisha's mouth and shoving the ones covered in saliva into her pussy. But even as she was getting plugged from both ends Alisha's gaze was directed at the way I was fucking Selene, an odd mixture of jealousy and proprietary pride warring with the haze of arousal on her face. She'd told me before that she loved seeing me with the others almost as much as she loved me taking care of her but I had never seen it so plainly on her face. The almost visceral joy she felt at seeing me fucking Selene and the jealousy of wishing I was plowing her instead were clear to see. And the fact that I could see it so clearly even through the hopeless arousal Yume was subjecting her to was even more remarkable.

But of course it paled in comparison to Selene's reactions. That first orgasm had clearly almost made her lose her mind because she was lying on the bed, a quivering mess, her arousal producing a puddle underneath us and openly drooling onto the bed, letting out soft whimpers every time I buried myself fully inside her, the walls of her pussy squirming and squeezing down around me, trying to get me to cum. But there was a problem with that. Unlike Alisha, who could only get pregnant one day every other month, and Yume, who could only get pregnant two weeks out of every year, Selene was still perfectly human. And while we did have maiden's tea to deal with that we still tried to avoid me cumming inside her.

So I considered where to finish. Most of the times I would either switch to one of the others or Selene would finish me off with her mouth but she was clearly too out of it to do that and I absolutely didn't want to neglect her by just switching to one of the others. So I decided to get a little mean.

I pulled out of both of her holes, eliciting a disappointed whimper from her, then placed my cock between her ass cheeks and started thrusting, squeezing them together with both hands to make them as tight as possible. Selene had a really remarkably sexy ass and there was more than enough of it to perfectly engulf my cock, still slippery with all the juices I'd fucked out of her before.

I wasn't sure whether the stimulation would do anything for her but just moments after I started I heard her moan again before she reached down and started rubbing her pussy. I wasn't sure what part was doing it for her. Maybe she just loved the feeling of me using her body for my own pleasure or maybe my cock rubbing her tight little pucker on every pass was enough stimulation for her but either way within seconds I had her moaning almost as loudly as when I'd been plowing her soppy little hole before.

“Goddessh..." Alisha whimpered, now on her hands and knees and openly staring at us as Yume kept working her from both sides. I was a little bit surprised with how aggressive the little fox was being with the elf. Was she emulating the way I treated Alisha or was she naturally domineering and only submitted to me?

“You're next," I told her, my voice coming out in a ragged gasp. “You know that, right?”

“Yesshh," she whined, the word coming out even more gargled as Yume forced her fingers deeper into her mouth.

I broke eye contact with her just as Yume started to really work her pussy, making her moan and whimper as she was teased relentlessly, and focused on my cock sandwiched between Selene's delicious buns. At this point it was a struggle just to hold on and I leaned down and growled into her ear:

“Get ready for it.”

“Uh-huh," she whimpered and I bucked harder between her cheeks.

Finally, when I could no longer hold it in, I came, shooting rope after rope of cum all over her back, reaching all the way to her shoulder blades with the first four and then coating her lower back with three more before the deluge finally stopped. At each blast hitting her skin she shivered, then finally just lay there breathing.

“Gods above, that looks amazing," Yume said, giving voice to my own thoughts.

Selene's body was toned and fit, with curves fit for a goddess, her skin lightly tanned and currently flushed from exertion and arousal, and a thick frosting of cum covered all of her back, making her look used and filthy, even more so with the puddle of juices that had gathered underneath her.

Oh crap. We'd wanted to keep the sheets clean, hadn't we?

I mentally shrugged as I looked at my handiwork. It might be mortifying one day but I honestly couldn't bring myself to care, especially when a moment later Alisha and Yume descended upon Selene, eagerly licking off the sticky treat I'd left all over the paladin's back.

As the two of them busied themselves I crawled over to lay down next to Selene and cupped her cheek before gently kissing her. She could barely move and so she only barely returned the kiss but she did her best, moving her lips against me just enough to show me how much she appreciated me.

When we broke the kiss I laid back down and just watched as Alisha and Yume kept licking my cum off of her back, licking and slurping and occasionally sharing a deep kiss to pass the sticky treat back and forth. It was so hot I had to swallow as I watched them.

“I think our lover likes it," Yume said before giving Alisha's chin a lick to get an errant strand of cum off of it.

“Really?” Alisha whined.

“I love it,” I said. “I love you.”

Alisha shivered at those words and Yume smirked, then slipped a hand between the elf's thighs and began rubbing her again.

“I'm sure our lover wants to show you how much he appreciates you,” the little fox purred.

“Does he?” Alisha asked, rolling her hips against Yume's hand.

“So fucking much,” I told her, then sat up and pulled her towards me and cradled her in my arms.

She melted into me, there was no other word to describe it. Her body always felt as if it were made for me but no she curled herself up against me, every curve of her fitting perfectly against me, her skin almost feverish against mine.

“You did something really filthy there, you know?” I murmured into her ear, referring to the way she'd licked my ass earlier.

“Did you hate it?” she asked softly.

“It was mortifying,” I told her. “It was shocking and it was filthy and I'm not sure I would have allowed it if you'd asked me first.”

She shrank in on herself but I continued and almost growled into her ear:

“And I fucking love you for it.” And then I kissed her, deep and hard, showing her that no matter how filthy she was, no matter how much she'd debased herself for me, no matter where those lips had been before, I loved her and cherished her.

“You really don't mind?”

“I heard you talking about it with Amelia, you know?” I said and heard her breathing hitch. “So I want to know why you did it. Was it because it was something new or...?”

She somehow did the impossible and blushed even harder. “It's... the way she described it it's the most intimate thing a woman can do for her man, the kind of thing she'll only do for someone she loves and the kind of thing he'll only allow if he really trusts her. I... wanted to see if we're like that.”

I swallowed but then cracked a smile. “That sounds a little lofty, considering...”

“Alright, fine,” she said. “I also really wanted to try it out because it sounded filthy and debasing and submissive, alright?”

I chuckled. “Good girl. Now, I think you deserve a reward. Both for what you did and for being so honest with me. Would you like that?” And to punctuate my statement I let my hand slip between her thighs, finding her hot and soaking wet.

“Yesss,” she hissed, rolling her hips against my hand.

“Then come over here,” I said and pulled her on top of me, her back pressed against my chest. I snaked my legs around hers, locking them in place and making her all but worthless, then wrapped an arm around her throat, bending her head back. Only then, when I had her completely helpless and at my mercy, did I reach down to guide my cock inside her pussy.

Her tight little hole welcomed me back the way it always did, already slick with arousal for me, wrapping and writhing around me as if it never wanted to let go, and I fucked it in slow, deep thrusts that I knew would turn her into a whimpering, quivering mess.

Alisha got off on rough treatment and slow and gentle lovemaking absolutely drove her wild with need. And as a reward for being such a filthy good girl I gave her both. I had her utterly helpless and unable to do anything, my arm wrapped around her throat and applying just enough pressure but the fucking I gave her was slow and deep, almost gentle but not quite, sawing my cock in and out of her in long, deliberate motions, scraping her insides on every pass, and only a few minutes in I had her practically sobbing on top of me, clutching the arm I had around her throat, begging me to let her come already but grinding her hips against me to tell me how much she loved what I was doing to her.

Selene and Yume were cuddling, each with a hand between the other's thigh, stroking each other lazily as they watched me giving Alisha her reward. The way I had her locked in place all of her gorgeous body was on full display for the two of them. Her flat tummy quivering and bulging slightly out every time I buried myself inside her, her small breasts with their beautiful pink little nipples heaving with each rasping breath she took, her pale skin reddened from arousal and exertion and unfulfilled need, and of course my cock plunging in and out of her, stretching her pink little pussy tight around it every time it filled her up, all of it was on full display for the two of them and that, too, was driving Alisha wild. She didn't merely enjoy watching me with the others, she also loved being watched when I fucked her.

I had already cum three times and knew I would be able to go for a good long while if I wanted and so I kept it up, working Alisha over slowly, her mind and body practically melting from the pleasure. By the time I felt tears dripping onto my skin I might have stopped once upon a time but I already knew her body inside and out. I knew that, for her, tears were a good thing. Tears meant that the pleasure was more than she could handle, in the best kind of way. We'd had a couple of very long and serious talks about that, when I'd stopped and she'd told me she'd wished I would have continued, that the tears hadn't been a sign of discomfort at all. These days the long talks were no longer necessary. I was just that in tune with her body. I didn't even consciously think of her tears as a bad thing anymore. When I felt the tears streaking down her cheeks and onto my collarbone I felt my lips quirk up into a smile, as I knew that she was going just as wild as I wanted her to.

I didn't know how long I continued. I kept sawing my cock in and out of her until the tears had stopped, until her whimpers had stopped, until she just lay atop me gasping like a fish, her body quivering uncontrollably. I had been keeping her on the brink of orgasm for longer than I ever had and I knew that just a little extra stimulation would cause her to explode.

Finally, when I could no longer hold on, I called Yume over with a gaze and the little fox laid down on top of us, pressing her curvy body into Alisha's mashing their breasts together and capturing her mouth in a ravenous kiss. Only then did I bury my cock inside Alisha with one final savage thrust and gave her clit a rough pinch.

“Fmmmmmck!” Alisha screamed into Yume's mouth, so loud that I knew that without the little fox muffling her cry my mom in the other building would have heard her. Her orgasm went on and on and on, her body trembling for long minutes and her pussy clamping down on me like a vise. As she came and came and came I pumped my cum inside her, with my cock buried deep within her, my own orgasm almost mind-blowing in its intensity, the cum flowing out of me not in powerful blasts but in a steady stream that left me seeing stars.

Only when I had nothing more to give and Alisha had finally come down from her high did I let go of her and she slid off me almost bonelessly.

She was shivering and gasping and I pulled her into me, spooning her and cooing at her, whispering sweet nothings into her ear as her fried mind slowly pulled itself together.

We fell asleep that way, me spooning Alisha, with Selene and Yume draped around the two of us, and the last thing I heard before sleep claimed me was Alisha letting out a soft little giggle before she muttered:

“If this is how you reward me I need to lick your butt more often...”