Vol.6 Ch.15.3 – Good Girl’s Reward III

Meli looked gorgeous, straddling Alisha like that. Her pale skin was flushed all over and glistened with sweat, her modest chest heaved and fell and her muscles flexed as she rose and dropped on the artificial cock lodged in her pussy. Kneeling behind her I couldn't see her expression but the moans coming out of her told me everything I needed to know.

I took my time admiring her, working a generous coating of slime essence onto my cock, before I ran my hands along her sides, causing her to falter and moan even sweeter.

“You like this?” I asked into her ear.

“Not as much as yours,” she whined.

“Don't worry,” I rumbled and let my hands slide down to her ass. I kneaded her cheeks a little before spreading them and poking at her twitching little hole with my slicked-up cock.

“No,” she whined. “That's too much. I can't take both at once.”

I wrapped one arm around her chest and with the other I tilted her head back to make her look at me. “Can't you try for me?” I asked her. “You can try for me, can't you?”

“I... I can try...” she whimpered. “But you'll be gentle, right?”

“Of course,” I rumbled, then pushed forward. Between Alisha's tongue and my fingers her asshole was nice and loose and sloppy, the ring of muscle offering no resistance as I pushed the tip inside. Only when I was inside did I feel it. Meli already had some tight holes, not quite virginal but not far from it, and with her pussy thoroughly plugged by the toy it was an enormous struggle to push deeper inside her. It wasn't that her hole was denying me entry, she was just stuffed full already.

But I pressed on. Slowly, glacially slowly I pressed my cock into her furnace-hot depths, moans and whimpers coming out of her intermittently.

“You're doing so well,” I cooed into her ear, reaching around to massage her sweet little tits.

“Yeah?” she whimpered.

“Yeah, you're such a good girl... Such a good girl...” Something about the praise made her insides relax, letting me slide inside a little easier. “Good girl...”

“Uuuuhh...” she whimpered. “I feel so full...”

“Do you like it?” I asked.

“Uh-huh...”

“Good girl...”

Finally, finally I was fully sheathed inside her, my hips flush against her ass cheeks.

“There we go,” I rumbled. “You did it. You took it all.”

“Uh-huh...”

“Good girl,” I rumbled, then reached down to rub her little clit as a reward, but when I got there I felt Alisha's fingers already doing it. And then I realized that I hadn't looked at Alisha once while I'd been busy cramming my cock into Meli's ass.

Alisha looked gorgeous down there. She was just as flushed and sweaty as Meli but rather than writhing in ecstasy she seemed to be rather frustrated. That was a new one. Normally she enjoyed watching me fuck our other lovers in front of her. But then I realized what the problem was: The harness was keeping her from playing with her pussy, so the only stimulation she was getting was the harness grinding into her clit and her hand somewhat desperately fiddling with one nipple.

“Jealous?” I asked as I dragged my cock out of Meli and then pushed inside again.

The second thrust was easier than the first, the third was easier than the second. And by the time I thrust inside Meli for the fourth time Alisha managed to answer:

“Yes.” She didn't sound upset, despite the frustration. She knew that this was punishment to some extent. But even if this was punishment, I wasn't going to be too cruel to her.

“Once I'm done with her it's your turn,” I said. “Think your butt can handle me?”

She bit her lip. “I hope so.” I was beginning to suspect she had already used some powdered unicorn horn on herself in anticipation of this.

“What about you?” I asked Meli. By this point I had a decent rhythm going on, sawing in and out of her ass with slow, deep strokes that, from the sounds she was making, felt just as amazing for her as they did for me. She was unreasonably tight at the best of times but now it was like her insides were trying to melt and strangle my cock.

“I can't... can't take it anymore...”

“Come for me,” I rumbled. “Come on my cock like a good girl.”

As if I'd cast a spell on her she came instantly, shrieking out her pleasure, her body going rigid. Through it all I kept sawing in and out of her. I had only been with Melinoe a handful of times but I'd had enough experience with women coming their brains out lately that I knew there was more for her to give me.

And so I kept fucking her, slowly, deeply, pulling out until my tip was only barely inside her and then pushing all the way in, going with the rhythm of her breathing. When I felt her coming down from her high her breathing evened out for only a moment before she started blubbering again.

“Oh gods, again, I'm gonna...”

“Come for me you gorgeous little slut,” I growled and once again she lost her mind.

“FUUUCK!”

I pulled her close, squeezing her breasts tightly as I drew her against me.

Just as I'd known that I could work another orgasm out of her earlier, the way her body seized up this time told me she was done, that any more would just be painful for her. And while a little pervert like Alisha would enjoy that sort of thing, Melinoe was more delicate and so I wouldn't overwhelm her like that. And so I held her against me until she slowly came down from her high, her body gradually going limp until she collapsed almost bonelessly atop Alisha.

“Good girl,” I cooed into her ear. “You did so well.”

In response she only whimpered and I gently pulled her off us, placing her on the bed. Lubricant and her own juices leaked from her thoroughly fucked holes and she was shivering gently, so I placed the blanket over her before turning back to Alisha.

She'd lost the harness by that point but she knew better than to play with her neglected pussy. Instead she was already folded over, presenting her holes to me. I had half a mind to make her suck Meli's ass off my cock and then fuck her pussy but I'd already tasted that sweet little hole tonight. And, again, this was still something of a punishment.

So I took my cock, thoroughly lubed up as it was, and lined it up with her little pucker.

“Ready?” I asked.

“Give it me,” she whined.

I pushed inside, watching her expression like a hawk. I was fine with making her a little uncomfortable but if it actually hurt her I would stop. She liked pain but the pain of overstretching her asshole was something completely different from, say, getting her ass spanked for being a little brat.

But she wasn't in pain. Taking me in her ass without preparation was clearly a struggle for her but I had spent long enough molding her ass into the perfect hole to fuck and it yielded to me easily.

“There we go,” I said. “Do you like it?”

“Yessss...” she hissed. “It feels so good.”

“Was it worth the frustration?” I asked as I pulled out.

“Uh-huh,” she whined, holding herself open. “She looked so sexy on top of me. And you taking her ass...”

“If only you'd been able to touch yourself...” I teased.

“A little bit of frustration makes it better,” she said, her mouth falling open into a little 'o' as I pushed inside her again.

“Really?” I asked. “So how about you suck me off and then I send you to bed?”

She glared at me.

I chuckled as I picked up a rhythm. “No, I wouldn't do that. You did so well tonight.”

“Really?” she asked. She didn't go quite as insane from praise as Meli did but she still sought it.

“Yeah,” I said. “If you want, you can play with your pussy.” She reached out but then stopped herself as she realized I wasn't done yet. “Or you keep those hands to yourself and we can kiss while I ream your ass.”

Instantly her hands were at her sides and she closed her eyes and opened her mouth.

“Good girl,” I said, then leaned down to kiss her.

We made out while I worked her ass, sawing in and out of her hole as she gradually got used to it, picking up the pace as she started to yield to me, her moans leaking into my mouth more and more. She was getting close. Good, because so was I. I'd held back so much I knew I'd be filling her to capacity once I reached my limit.

“Where do you want it?” I growled as I broke the kiss.

“Fill me up,” she begged. “I want it as deep as you can.”

“You asked for it,” I growled, then gave one last brutal thrust that buried me to the hilt in her ass.

A moment later I came. It was the kind of brutal, overwhelming orgasm that made me see stars. The sound of my cum filling up her ass was actually audible, a thoroughly filthy and sexy squelching sound.

Between that last thrust, the cum filling her up and the filthy sounds, Alisha came as well. It wasn't the shrieking orgasm she'd had earlier, and neither was it the overwhelming orgasm Meli had just had. It was a relief, like she'd been searching for this high for so long and had finally found it. She came with a groan that went on and on, her asshole not clamping down on me but quivering around me as she rode out the tidal wave.

Finally, when I had nothing more to give and could move again, I pulled out of her, slowly. As I had suspected, she'd cleaned herself out earlier, as the cum running out of her gaping hole was still pearly white, and once I had pulled out my entire length I saw her opening her mouth and wriggling her tongue.

I didn't ask if she was sure. I knew her, I trusted her. And so I simply crawled over and knelt atop her head, then fed the tip of my dick into her waiting mouth.

She wasn't trying to get me to cum again. She was cleaning me up slowly, thoroughly, nursing on my cock as we both came down from our high.

“Good girl,” I rumbled.

“Mhm...”