Vol.5 Ch.3 – Goddess And Priestess, Worshiping At The Same Altar

Chapter 3: Goddess And Priestess, Worshiping At The Same Altar

“You know, even I don't ask him for permission to come,” Alisha said, more than a hint of smugness in her voice. Apparently the little pervert elf thought she'd finally found someone who was even more submissive than she was. Well, she wasn't wrong about that.

“Shut up,” Athena grumbled. “It just slipped out.”

“You don't have to be embarrassed about it,” I told her, gently stroking her hair as I held her head in my lap. “If you keep being a good girl I'll let you come whenever you need to.”

“Fuck you, Tailor,” she muttered but her heart wasn't in it. “And stop poking me.”

I snorted. I was rock-hard and with the way her head was in my lap my cock poked into the back of her head whenever it twitched, which it was doing rather a lot with two gorgeous women on the bed with me.

“I don't think he can help that,” Alisha said. “But you can.”

“What do you mean?”

“Turn around,” Alisha said, her voice turning husky.

Athena raised an eyebrow at her but then turned around, propped herself up on her elbows, and saw what had been poking her. Without her head holding it down my cock stood tall, already dripping precum.

“O-Oh,” she whimpered as she saw what she had done to me.

“You should help him out,” Alisha said.

“What about you?”

“I want to see how you suck his cock,” Alisha breathed, making the word sound extra filthy.

Athena stared up at me and the sight of her embarrassed face made my cock jerk, drawing her attention back to it.

“Go on, Athena,” I said. “You've been such a good girl tonight.”

“Fucking bastard,” she muttered, and then opened her mouth to take me in.

It felt amazing. She clearly had no idea what she was doing but her eagerness made up for it. She had her lips wrapped firmly around my crown and her tongue was swirling around the tip as she applied the slightest bit of suction to it. That alone was great but the serene look on her face, as if she were enjoying a delicacy, that's what made it amazing.

Alisha was clearly liking what she saw as well because she grabbed my hand and pressed it between her thighs, letting me feel her soaking wet pussy. I started rubbing her, feeling her little nub gradually hardening under my fingers, as she gently placed a hand on the back of Athena's head, urging her to take me deeper.

And she did. Or rather, she tried, leaning down to swallow half my length and nearly choking on it. She pulled back retching and cleared her throat before going back in, now trying to bob up and down, taking a quarter of my length on every stroke.

“You're much better at this than Felix told me,” Alisha praised and in response Athena's whole face took on a shade of deep red.

She pulled herself off my cock and asked: “He told you ab—BUH!!” before Alisha shoved her back down onto my cock.

I leaned over and gave the little elf a gentle kiss, then asked: “How about you show her how it's done, love?”

Alisha bit her lip, then husked: “Of course, love.”

She slid down next to Athena and I spread my legs to accommodate both of them. She gently stroked Athena's cheek and cooed, praising her without words for how well she was doing. And she was. Even if she could only take a quarter of me in her mouth she was making the most of it, grabbing my cock at the base and squeezing just so. Apparently she'd noticed that a certain amount of pressure made it feel that much better.

Finally, when she couldn't take it anymore she pulled back and took a deep, gulping breath.

“How was that?” she demanded.

“I've had better,” I said. She had been great but I just couldn't stop myself from fucking with her. But I didn't want her to feel bad so I amended: “But it was alright for your second time.”

Despite herself Athena smiled at the almost-compliment. The unreasonable amount of pride she took from this faint praise was a little adorable, though it also made me wonder just how starved for affection the goddess truly was underneath the haughty exterior.

“Let me have a taste,” Alisha said, pulling her out of her reverie.

Instead of simply leaning out of the way Athena used her grip on my cock to point it at Alisha's lips. In response the little elf sank down and swallowed my cock, immersing herself in my scent and flavor the way she always did. Alisha did not merely enjoy pleasing me, she loved the act of sucking me off. She had told me many times and the way she delighted in teasing out my reactions and tasting me couldn't be mistaken for anything else. And Athena could clearly tell the difference.

The goddess stared at Alisha wide-eyed, her expression a mixture of jealousy and longing. She didn't merely want to be as good at it as Alisha was, she wanted to enjoy it the way Alisha did. And so she studied her, studied the way Alisha was swirling her tongue around my cock as if trying to savor the flavor, studied the way she moaned softly and massaged her breast, studied the serene expression on her face and, finally, she reached out and stroked Alisha's cheek.

The little elf responded by letting my cock slip out of her mouth as she gave Athena a seductive look through lidded eyes. “Go on,” she said softly as she pointed my cock back at the goddess.

And Athena took me in again, licking and sucking, then took it out of her mouth to lick up the side. Alisha took it as an invitation and started working her lips along the other side until the two of them were practically making out with my cock in between their dancing tongues. Alisha reached out and cupped one of Athena's breasts and Athena in turn did the same for Alisha.

Finally, they let my cock slip from their mouths and Alisha caught Athena in a soft, gentle kiss as she kept pumping my cock with one hand.

Athena's reaction to the kiss was adorably awkward. She stiffened when Alisha's lips met hers, her eyes going wide, then melted into it and finally sighed and closed her eyes as she got into it. Her reactions were so obvious she might as well have been speaking her thoughts out loud. Her desires had been focused on me to such an extent that she had clearly never considered intimacy with others and now she was learning that it was not just possible but felt amazing.

But their kiss didn't last. When Athena came up for air Alisha took my cock in again, swallowing it down further and further until the entire thing was hilted down her throat and she was lapping at my balls as best she could with her mouth open. Rivulets of saliva streamed out of her mouth and ran down my sensitive skin, getting my balls slick and wet.

“Gods above,” I ground out, “you're fucking amazing, Alisha.”

She pulled back again and gave me a toothy grin as she pointed my cock at Athena's mouth once more.

The goddess took me in again, far more enthusiastic than before but nowhere near as stimulating as an expert like Alisha. This time she did manage to take a third of me down her throat, though.

“How was that?” Athena asked as she resurfaced.

“Not as good as Alisha,” I said honestly as Alisha went back in, this time sucking on my balls directly and then kissing her way lower. Was she going to...?

But I was pulled out of wondering what Alisha was and wasn't going to do when a red-faced Athena asked:

“How come all I get is derision while she gets praise?”

I felt Alisha's hands on the backs of my knees and assisted her by pulling in my legs, completely exposing myself to her, instinctively showing her the absolute trust I had in her. And she repaid that trust by pressing her lips onto my pucker and making out with it the same way she'd made out with Athena earlier.

I leaned my head back for a moment and just enjoyed the sensation as I heard Athena making flabbergasted noises at the filthy act. Finally I looked back at her and answered her question: “Because Alisha does stuff like this for me.”

“But... that's so filthy.”

Alisha broke her passionate liplock with my ass just long enough to say: “Not at all. He keeps himself very clean for me.”

“B-but...” Athena whimpered, but she wasn't thinking about Alisha anymore. “Does that even feel good?”

“It feels fucking amazing,” I said as Alisha's lips moved gently against my sensitive flesh, her tongue flicking out and licking gently.

“Would...” Athena began, then paused. “Would you praise me if I... If I...”

All the gods above and below, was this really going to happen? Was she really so desperate to get praised that she was willing to go that far?

“Yes, Athena.”

I could feel the smile spreading over Alisha's face before she pulled away from me, getting out of the way for Athena to take her place.

The goddess slid into place slowly, her movements halting and languid as if sleepwalking. Apparently Athena couldn't believe she was about to do this any more than I did.

She leaned down until she was almost in the right position and looked up, her gaze seeking mine. She didn't look angry, didn't look defiant, didn't even look embarrassed. She seemed skittish, terrified that I might say something mean, worried that I wouldn't appreciate what she was going to do. But gods, I did.

I gave her a slight nod and she leaned forward, pressing her divine lips against my pucker.

I will spare you the stream of expletives that came out of my mouth at the unbelievable feeling of the goddess I'd spent a decade hating eating my ass. My mind was completely fried from the situation. The goddess who had scorned me for all those years was doing this not because I had forced her into it but because she was so desperate for me, a mortal, the mortal she had belittled for years, to praise her. And I did.

“Oh fuck... Athena, that feels fucking amazing.”

“Uh-huh?” she asked, not even interrupting her kissing and licking.”

“Yeah,” I wheezed out. “You're doing so well.”

She let out a happy little humming sound and got even more into it, grabbing hold of my buttocks and licking with ever more enthusiasm.

“You want to cum, don't you?” Alisha husked into my ear.

“Gods yes,” I ground out.

“Then let me help you,” she said, then sank down and swallowed my cock down to the base once more.

It was too much. Between a literal goddess debasing herself between my ass cheeks and Alisha swallowing me down to the root I couldn't hold on. I did everything I could think of, every trick I'd ever learned to stave off my orgasm, but it was no use. Within moments I was shooting blast after blast of cum down my beautiful elf's throat until I had nothing more to give.

**

I was lying on the bed bonelessly with Alisha curled into my side, my ears full of white noise as I simply breathed, trying to process the intense pleasure. The sensation hat certainly been amazing but it had been the situation that had made it unbearable.

“Was it good?” Athena asked timidly.

I beckoned her over to curl into my other side and said:

“You were so amazing.” I patted the top of her head. “Good girl.”

For a moment I was worried she would misunderstand this, that she would think I was making fun of her, but when I looked back at her I saw that she had a big, stupid grin on her face. It was so adorable I just had to pull her into a kiss.

“And what about me?” Alisha asked.

I turned around and kissed her as well.

“You, too.”

We just lay there for a moment before Athena asked: “You... you're not done with us yet, right?”

I snorted. “You think I'm done with you when I haven't turned you both inside out yet?”

She actually sagged in relief at that.

“Pervert goddess,” I said and she blushed and averted her gaze. But I wasn't having any of that. I reached down and cupped a good handful of her ass, then said: “On your stomach. I've got something special planned for you.”

She didn't even ask what it was, she just complied immediately. Gods above, not even Alisha was this quick to follow my orders. Alright, fair enough, the only reason Alisha ever hesitated was because she loved it when I punished her for not obeying me, but still. Athena simply flipped onto her stomach as soon as I'd said the words.

“Alisha love?”

“Yeah?” the elf asked.

“Sit down on Athena for a bit. Pin her hands, too. I don't want her to squirm away.”

“What are you planning?” she asked.

I leaned in close so I could whisper into her ear and told her.

“Oh goddess...” Alisha swooned, then immediately complied, sitting down on Athena's back side-saddle and crossing the goddess' arms behind her back.

I might have been more careful about putting Athena into such a helpless position but the moment Alisha grabbed her wrists to restrain her I saw the pervert goddess biting her lip. She was loving the treatment. I was quite curious to see how much she would like the next part.

I spread her legs and sat down in between them, her gorgeous ass on full display. I kneaded her cheeks a little, then gave them a few smacks, just to get them all nice and red, forcing some adorable squeaking noises out of the bitch goddess.

Finally I spread her cheeks apart and just took in the view. Her gorgeous pussy that I had deflowered was soaking wet from anticipation already and above it the tight pucker of her asshole twitched cutely. And that was my goal. I reached over to my nightstand and pulled out a little thimble of powdered unicorn horn, then poured half the contents in between her cheeks.

She yelped as the powder got to work on her sensitive flesh and I leaned over to pet her head as I cooed: “Shh, it's alright. It only tingles for a little bit.”

“What was that?” she asked.

“Powdered unicorn horn,” I said. “It cleans impurities.”

“I know what powdered unicorn horn does,” she said, sounding flustered. “But why are you pouring that on my... my...?”

“I'm pouring it on your asshole because I'm going to be fucking that asshole, obviously.”

Her breathing hitched. “But... but that... That's not what that place is for...”

I let a drop of slime essence hit her little pucker, then started massaging it into her wrinkled flesh with two fingers. For a few moments she made uncomfortable noises but soon enough I could hear her breathing quicken and her saw her hips beginning to roll.

“You seem to be enjoying it well enough despite that,” I replied only once there was no way for her to deny that she was getting aroused from it.

“That's not what I meant,” she whimpered. Her hole had loosened up enough that I could slip the tip of a finger inside her with no resistance and she let out an adorable squeak as her greedy hole swallowed my finger. “Obviously it feels good. I could tell you liked it when I... licked... yours. But...! This isn't a hole for procreation. There is no reason to be playing with this hole!”

I could finally slip both fingers inside her with no resistance and began to fuck her with them, first only to the first knuckle but gradually sinking deeper. “Precisely,” I said. “There is no reason for me to fuck this hole. There is no chance you can get pregnant from it whatsoever.”

“So what's the point then?”

“The point is,” I said, and I paused long enough to sink my two fingers all the way inside her greedy ass before I continued, “that there is no point. The only reason to fuck this hole is for pleasure. We're doing this for no other reason than to get off.”

She digested that comment for a while longer, then she started chuckling. “There is a certain poetry to it, isn't there?”

“There is,” I agreed. “You want pleasure and that's exactly what I'm giving you. Pure, mindless pleasure with no higher reason or logic behind it.”

At that her reactions instantly became more enthusiastic. She thrust her rump back at me, trying to fuck herself onto my fingers as best she could with Alisha sitting on her. I had assumed she would like this idea and was glad to already know this much about her.

“May I touch myself?” she asked timidly. Her hands were still held behind her back, after all.

I raised an eyebrow at Alisha, leaving the decision to her.

In response Alisha gave Athena's ass a smack. “Nope. All of Felix' women need to be able to come from their butts. You either get off from his cock in your ass or you don't get to come at all.”

I raised my eyebrows at Alisha's words and Athena whined in response. Apparently the little elf enjoyed making other women submit to me almost as much as she enjoyed submitting to me.

“Then please...”

“Please what?” Alisha asked, giving Athena's ass another smack.

“Please use me,” Athena whined.

Alisha let out a cruel little chuckle. “Use you? You mean you're fine with him getting himself off between your cheeks and leaving you all frustrated? Again?”

Athena grumbled into the mattress.

“If you want something, say it clearly,” Alisha said.

Athena hesitated for a whole three heartbeats before she all but screamed: “Please, Felix, fuck my ass until I come!”

Gods above, the sheer desperation in her voice was almost overwhelming. Almost.

“Alisha, get off her. Athena, turn around. I want to see your face when I stick it in your ass for the first time.”

Alisha hurried to get off the goddess and slid into place behind me, pressing her supple curves into my back and looking over my shoulder as Athena got herself into position. I could feel the little elf playing with my nipples but the sensation was mere background noise compared to the sight of Athena on her back, her legs pulled close and her now slightly gaping, twitching asshole exposed. The flesh was reddened and she seemed to ache for my cock.

“Are you ready to have your last virginity taken as well?” I asked her, hammering home what exactly I was about to do to her.