Chapter 46: I Want to Try It!

“I want to try it!”

The elf’s impertinent request rang in Lexi’s ears like the sound of a gong, waking her violently from the dreamlike trance of orgasmic bliss into which her consciousness sank when the curse overtook her. So stunned was Lexi by Danica’s interjection that she turned quickly in the elf’s direction, causing her cock to slip out of Gretel’s asshole with an audible plop. A veritable river of thick white cum oozed out of her pink hole, temporarily gaped from the thick futa cock which had just been fucking it, thick globs dripping down into her glistening pussy lips to drip noisily into the water beneath her hips.

“Y-You want to t-try…that?” Lexi stuttered incredulously, gesturing in a panning motion at both her thick cock as well as Gretel’s winking asshole, from which stringy globs of white cum still leaked.

“Mmmm,” Gretel moaned lustily, rocking her hips back, bouncing her ample ass cheeks against the side of Lexi’s semi-hard cock. “Put it back,” the mage purred. “Mama wants some more.”

However, Lexi was too distracted by the enthusiastic young elf, whose excitement was so palpable that her ears were practically vibrating, bouncing up and down so fast that the paladin was reminded of a hummingbird taking flight.

“But, you already had your turn,” Danica pouted. “I want to do sex with Lexi’s big thingie. You looked sooo cool when you were doing it, Gretel. And, it looked like you were having so much fun. But, I thought that when you did sex the boy’s thingie — or I guess the girl’s thingie is she’s a futa-whatever-you-call-it — went in the girl’s slit, not in her butt? I mean, I have some neat little wooden thingies that I made to play with, but I’ve never tried putting them in my butt like that, only in my slit — and that’s great — but since it looked like you liked it so much, maybe it’d be fun for me too, and—”

“Well!” Gretel interrupted, forcefully cutting off the elf’s mile-a-minute speech. “There’s really only one way to find out if you like it in the butt…”

“B-But her th-thingie is so big,” Danica stuttered, an edge of fear clearly tinging her excitement. “And my b-butt is so small. It’s kinda scary for me since—”

“Don’t let Gretel bully you into trying something that you’re not totally ready for,” Lexi said, as she pulled the elf in close, giving her a reassuringly soft caress on the shoulder. “Just because she’s a butt slut, it doesn’t mean that you have to be.”

“Butt slut!” Gretel exclaimed with mock indignation. Scooping a handful of Lexi’s cum out of her still leaking ass, she smeared it playfully on the paladin’s lips and cheek. “That’s what you get when you call me names after taking advantage of my poor little ass.”

“Har har har,” Lexi said, scooping the cum into her mouth with a single finger and licking it clean. “You’re just so hilarious.”

“Aren’t I?” the mage said grinning.

“Anyway,” the paladin said, turning her attention back to the small elf clinging to her side, staring in wonder at the cum slicked cock still pulsing with the futanari’s vitality. “If you’re sure that you want to try having sex, maybe we should try it the normal way first, in the pussy. If you like that, then we can see what you think about trying out some butt stuff later. How’s that sound?”

Danica was too excited to articulate a response, so Lexi took the squealing and clapping as the elf being in agreement with her proposal.

“So,” Gretel said slyly, sidling up on the other side of the elf, pressing the side of a large breast against the side of Danica’s face. “Is there any room for me in this little arrangement? And what about Samantha, I’m sure she’d like to join the party too.”

The elf’s eyes slowly panned to the left meeting Gretel’s light pink nipple, snapped down to her own nearly flat chest, and then back up to the mage’s pillowy boob. A bloom of red spread quickly across Danica entire face, reaching the tips of her ears. Clearly, the small girl was intimidated not only by Gretel’s enormous breasts, but also by her “threat” of turning a twosome into an orgy.

“I…w-well…it’s j-just…” Danica stuttered nervously. The elf was clearly not into Gretel’s proposal, but was too daunted by the well-endowed mage to openly decline the proposition. Thankfully, Samantha came, unbidden, to the smaller girl’s rescue.

A dark shadow fell over the mage, as Samantha’s titanically proportioned figure rose up from the steaming spring water behind her, like some eldritch beast emerging from the depths. Feeling the monk’s presence behind her, Gretel’s expression turned into a nervous smile as beads of sweat prickled her brow. Without a word, Samantha placed a large brown hand atop the mage’s pink haired head.

“Uh oh,” Gretel said, her eyes growing wide at the realization of what was likely coming.

The monk’s rippling muscles exploded into motion, her enormous bicep flexing as she pulled back on the mage’s head, dunking Gretel backwards into the water as easily as if she were a small child. Samantha’s characteristic slight smile tugged up at the corner’s of her mouth, eyes twinkling in the evening light, while she held the thrashing Gretel beneath the bubbling water’s surface for a few seconds. After a look from Lexi, the monk released the mage, and Gretel came bobbing to the surface, sputtering and coughing up mouthfuls of hot water.

“I think,” Samantha said to Gretel, when the mage snapped her gaze up to meet the monk’s steely gray eyes. “That since it is the little one’s first time, that it would be best if she and Lexi were given some privacy.”

“Whatever!” Gretel snapped, splashing a handful of water up into Samantha’s face, wetting the monk’s shaggy white bangs. “Although,” the mage muttered so low that Lexi barely heard it. “It’s not like I got any privacy from the shrimp when she was like an inch away from my asshole getting creampied.”

The comment apparently did not go unheard by Samantha either, because the monk placed her hand dangerously atop Gretel’s head once more. The threat of another dunking was enough to make the mage clap her mouth shut with an audible snap.

“Great point,” Lexi said laughing. “And well argued, Samantha. In fact, since you two’re already having so much fun, why don’t you and Gretel go off and ‘play’ while Danica and I get to know each other.”

Lexi looked down at the elf, giving her another reassuring squeeze, and was pleased to see a look of relief spread across her pretty face, her long ears bobbing up and down happily.

“But first,” the paladin continued. “I need to have a quick word with our spellcasting friend.” Lexi pulled Gretel aside, swimming out to the pool’s center. Bringing the other girl in so close that the tips of their noses touched, Lexi whispered, “I’ve got a surprise for you. Samantha really enjoyed this last night, and I’m sure you will too.”

A quizzical expression passed over Gretel’s face as her brows knotted in confusion, but before she could ask Lexi what she meant by the cryptic statement, the paladin had slipped her hand down to caress the mage’s pussy, holding it gently in the palm of her hand, and subvocalized the command word needed to cast her spell.

Futanarization!

Gretel’s eyes nearly popped out of her head as she felt the wave of magical energy coursing through her curvy body. With Lexi’s hand still cupping her pussy, the mage’s clit began to rapidly expand, growing thicker and longer until it completely overflowed the paladin’s cupped palm. In place of the small hooded nub, the mage now possessed her very own futa cock, which — even in its currently flaccid state — nearly as large and girthy as Lexi’s own.

“Whaaat?!” Gretel whisper-yelled into Lexi’s ear? “H-How did y-you—”

“New spell,” Lexi answered shortly, altering her grip on Gretel’s newly formed cock from cupping to one more suitable for stroking. “It’ll only last for about ten minutes, so you’ll need to make the most of it.”

Gretel clutched at the paladin’s bare shoulders, burying her face in the crook of Lexi’s neck to avoid crying out in pleasure as her cock was expertly stroked into a rock hard erection. The sheer novelty of the cascade of sensations emanating from this wondrous new organ sprouting proudly from the crest of her labia was so intense that Gretel was worried she was going to cum right there in Lexi’s hand. Fortunately, the paladin read her friend’s reactions perfectly, and backed off just in time, leaving the futanarized mage in a seriously horny state of arousal.

“Keep it on the down low until you’re ready for prime time though,” Lexi said, giving the mage a devilish wink. “If it were me I’d probably try and surprise Samantha with a nice juice cock in her twat when she was least expecting it. But, it’s your cock to use, so get fucking.”

“Yes ma’am,” Gretel replied with a mock salute, and swam over to Samantha, taking the enormously muscular woman by the hand and leading her over to the other side of the pool — all the while keeping her new ‘toy’ submerged under the water’s cloudy surface.

Lexi could hardly help but stare at the pair as they made their way across the pool, imagining what kinds of sexy hijinks the curvaceous mage and ripplingly muscled monk were in for. The futanari could hardly not feel a surge of hormone-fueled blood surge into her own cock just thinking about Gretel’s pillowy tits bouncing wildly while she slammed her new magical cock between Samantha’s brown pussy lips. Before Lexi knew it, the tip of her cock had poked its head out of the water, like a submarine’s periscope.

Her own arousal now in full force once again, Lexi turned her gaze back to the tiny elf, who had undoubtedly been watching the interaction between her and the mage intently, desperate to know what secret mischief the pair were getting up to. But, when Danica saw Lexi’s cock bobbing in her direction as the paladin made her way back toward the elf, all thoughts of anything but cock were violently ejected from the elf’s mind. By the time Lexi made it back to Danica’s side of the pool, the elf’s mouth was literally hanging open, the expression on the small girl’s face looking like a child eager to start devouring an enormous slice of birthday cake.

“Lemme suck it again!” Danica blurted out, her ears quivering with excitement, unable to hold out any longer.

Without even waiting for a response from Lexi, Danica quite literally dove forward into the water, her mass of golden hair rising to the surface just centimeters from Lexi’s now raging hard on. The tiny girl once again wrapped both of her hands around the shaft of Lexi’s thick futa cock, neither one being large enough to completely encircle the girthy shaft, and leaned in to start licking the glistening red tip like it was a lolly pop. The elf’s technique still left a lot to be desired, but her sheer enthusiasm was second to none. Lexi’s cock almost immediately responded to her efforts, leaking a stream of glistening clear precum that the elf noisily lapped up.

“It’s so yummy!” she said, smacking her lips in approval.

Lexi was actually in danger from the sheer sensory overload of the tiny elf’s childlike cuteness combined with the enthusiastic cock licking she was delivering. With a great effort of willpower, the futanari pulled her cock out of Danica’s grasp. Panting slightly, she looked down at the small girl with a mixture of endearment and lust visible on her face.

“Actually,” Lexi purred. “I was thinking that I might get a chance to lick you first.”