Chapter 5: Foreplay and Lily’s Defloration

“Remove the gag” Emily’s voice comes through the earpiece.

I obediently follow her and lift Lily’s head to remove it. I was prepared for a scream but it didn’t come. Instead, a slight moan leaks out of her mouth.

What is this? Lily’s face is completely red now, a darker shade than before. She is breathing heavily from her mouth.

“Ahn….haa…haa…haa…umu,” she moans and gulps down the saliva in her mouth.

No matter how I look at it, she is in a clear state of arousal. No, not just arousal, extreme arousal, like a bitch in heat.

I shoot an angry look at Emily who is recording us.

“Okay, okay, I mixed an aphrodisiac as well, alright…” she says with her eyes twinkling mischievously, “…but she is not screaming, is she?”

What have you done, you lewd woman?

Yeah, she’s not screaming but panting like crazy. Fuck it, I don’t even care about this anymore. I am going to get this done with quickly and save my Lily.

“Okay, now, open her shirt” Emily’s next command came.

I took a breath and start unbuttoning Lily’s school uniform. Due to her being tied up, her shirt cannot be fully removed; nevertheless, her pure white stomach and huge boobs wrapped in a white sports bra come into my view.

Her stomach and cleavage are glistening with sweat, dyed in a faint red color.

“Now cut her bra off.” Emily’s next command came in as she pointed at the black bag lying beside me, the one from which she earlier took out the syringe.

Cut the bra off? Man…

Woh, I am going to see Lily’s boobs for the first time in my life. But I’m already determined, there is no need for any reluctance. I grab the bag and quickly find the scissors inside. Without wasting any time, I cut the bra straps around both the shoulders and then cutting from the center, pulled out the bra off in one go.

“Nhaan…” Lily raises a moan.

Her huge boobs spill out. They are big, round and white. With cherry color nipples. Her areola is on the smaller side compared to Emily’s and they make her tits look amazing.

I feel myself staring at Lily’s tits; mesmerized by their wonderfulness.

“H-Hey, d-don’t compare…,” Emily says, looking a bit angry all of a sudden; though her eyes are also stuck at Lily’s boobs.

“Now, remember, this is rape, so I will need you to become rougher from now on,” Emily says while moving the recorder a bit, her voice suddenly changed to an aggressive tone.

“I am going to give you instructions a bit faster. So, get ready and follow them at once.”

I nod in her direction.

“Okay, now, grab both the tits.”

I feel my hands horribly shaking but I remind myself, I am doing this for Lily’s sake, well, mostly.

Moving my hands forward, I touch Lily tits lightly. A sudden soft feel spread on my palms. Her nipples brush against my fingers.

“Nhaan…” Lily leak a voice.

“I am not asking you to touch them, idiot, grab and squeeze them like you mean it,” Emily says with an exasperated look on her face.

I strengthen my grip and squeeze Lily’s breasts strongly. My fingers dig in so deeply that her breasts spilled out from in between my fingers, while her stiff nipples shifts to digging into my palm.

“Aaaaanh…..naaahan….” Lily’s voice grows a little louder.

I don’t want to lie, it feels like I am in heaven right now. Though both of my hands are tightly fixed on both the left and right boob, one set of hands is not capable of holding them. Both hands are needed to properly hold only one side.

“Okay, that’s enough, stop. Now pinch her nipples strongly and twist them. Also, pull the tits towards you as strongly as possible while doing that.” Emily says in a savage manner.

What the fuck? Isn’t it going too far? There is no way in hell anyone would feel good from that.

Emily is glaring at me, urging to start. Fuck, let’s do this.

I rub Lily’s nipples a little so that she can somehow feel less pain from what I am going to do. Wow, her nipples are really hard. From the touch, Lily leaks out another moan.

I take a deep breath and then slowly, pinch both of Lily’s nipple twisting them as hard as I can and pull both the boobs towards me at the same time.

“IYAAAAAAAAAN” Lily screamed on top of her lungs.

Oh shit, I think I twisted the nipples a bit too much. They are bright red right now. They are even trembling faintly from the pulsating blood.

“Very good!” Emily compliments while giving me a thumbs up sign.

Shut up.

“Now, I want you to go crazy. Suck those tits, lick them, bite her nipples, do whatever you want to do with them, but I want you to look like a madman doing that. I want to see a true rapist in you. Be sure to make her breast red and dripping from your saliva in the end.”

Were the instructions really written before? It feels like Emily’s just making them up. Fuck her. But I can’t take the risk. I need to follow what she says.

See, I am going to be honest. I am a high school virgin boy. I have never even seen a live naked body of a woman before Emily’s. And now suddenly I am presented with the naked boobs of the girl I love; ordered to go mad on them with our lives on the line.

My self-restraint has faltered.

In the next moment, I found my mouth attached to Lily’s tits. While I grab and suck on the left tit, my other hand tightly squeezes and plays with the nipple of the other one.

Lily’s moans are also getting louder with every passing moment. I traced every nook and cranny of her breast with my tongue, strongly sucking her white skin leaving hickeys. And when I finally bit her nipple, instead of another scream, she gave loud moan.

The aphrodisiac is clearly a bit too strong. I can tell that she is in a state of such arousal that even pain is converted into pleasure. When I finally finish with her breast, they really do like something crazy was done to them

Her boobs are overall red, with numerous hickeys covering them. Her nipples have turned to a brighter red and are extremely erect. I feel like scolding myself for overdoing it but this is also necessary; I followed Emily’s command perfectly.

“W-Wow”

I hear a strange voice and when I look back, Emily is standing there with one hand on her breast playing with her nipple and other hand on her crotch; rubbing her pussy vigorously.

She straightened hastily when she saw me looking at her in shock.

“G-Good Job, now fext, I-I mean, next,” she says, her voice shaking a bit.

“F-Flip her skirt, cut off her panty and then lick her pussy. Do it as roughly as you can. And remember to savor the taste of her pussy properly…”

What the fuck has savoring her pussy’s taste has to do with shooting this goddamn video?

But this time also I did not wait. I am also highly aroused. My penis is so erect that it’s actually a bit painful. I move down in a trance-like state and grabbed the hem of Lily’s skirt, flipping it up. Her pure white panty appears in a flash. The scenery here gives me a shock of surprise.

It looks as if Lily had peed herself. Her panties are completely wet from love juices. Even the bed below has a small wet spot. Her white, soft looking thighs glistening with love juices.

I grab the scissors again and cut both the side of her panty, pulling it off. In the next moment, her bare crotch appears before my eyes.

It feels like I have transcended…

She has really thin, small hair down there. As her legs are stretched from the ropes, Lily’s pussy is also in clear view. The first live pussy I have ever seen in my life. It is a bit small and has a really pretty color of light pink. The petals of her pussy are slightly open, leaking out love juices from within continuously in dripping fashion.

I feel my mouth moving towards Lily’s pussy on its own. From the base to the top, from left to right, my tongue travels across her pussy collecting her love juice inside my mouth. Delicious. Her love juice tastes so amazingly sweet that it feels like I am sucking into a ripe mango.

I hold both of her thighs in place, my fingers sinking deep inside her soft skin. In this position, I start licking and sucking lily’s pussy while continuously gulping down her love juices.

Frequent loud moans leak out from Lily’s mouth. I remove my hand from her thighs and using my fingers, spread her pussy out. From within, a small, bright red, ruby-like thing appears. So, this is Lily’s clitoris.

I lick her clit lightly, rolling my tongue around it and finally giving it strong suck.

“Iyaaaaaaaan….Ahaaaaaaaan,” Lily gives the loudest moan till now. Her whole body starts twitching wildly. I know she’s close to coming. I quicken my movements, making my tongue go wild.

“Uwaaaaaaan…..” Lily gave a long cry and her back lifts off of the bed, making an arch as her whole body starts jerking. After a few minutes, her spasming body settles down.

Lily came. I made her cum. Wow; this feeling is also good.

I also remove my face from Lily’s crotch but I kept my hand there to caress her pussy lightly. Lily is breathing very heavily. Light moans are leaking from her mouth with every stroke of my finger; love juices still dripping down.

I wait for my next instruction but they did not come. I look around and saw Emily. My eyes open wide.

She is sitting on the ground, her thighs wide open and her hand on her pussy; furiously rubbing it with her fingers. She even looks close to coming herself.

“Emily….” Natalie’s voice again resounded in the room.

Emily startles. She tries to quickly stand up, slips and fell down on her own puddle of love juices. She hastily gets up again and moves to the video recorder. She looks incredibly frustrated now.

“Fuck her!” she speaks angrily, looking at me as if saying that it’s my fault she didn’t cum.

Why the fuck were you even masturbating? Aren’t you here just to shoot the video? Wait, did you just told me to fuck Lily?

“I said…fuck her!” Emily repeats

This is it. I am going to take Lily’s virginity and give her mine…

I got on top of Lily nervously. My penis is so erect that it is hitting my stomach even when my whole body is facing down.

My virginity will be lost to the girl of my dreams. The girl I loved since I was 11. This is not how I imagined our first time would be together, but the situation calls for it, so this is the only way.

I grab my dick and position it in between Lily’s wide-open legs. Lily is not completely naked as her open school shirt and flipped skirt are still there, this immodest look excited me further. I place my dick on top of her pussy and pushed a little; the tip of my cock went inside.

“NOOOOOOOOOOOO”

And for the first time since I removed the gag, a word came from Lily’s mouth along with an earsplitting scream. I retracted back in surprise, the tip of my cock coming out.

It seems that the aphrodisiac has stopped working. I look at Emily for help but she looks equally bewildered.

“The aphrodisiac should be working for at least another hour,” Emily says, confused. “In fact, it’s effect should be at its peak now.”

I frowned a little and try to put my dick inside Lily once more, but again, as soon as the tip got in she raises another scream, this time thrashing her body wildly; pulling on her restraints.

I try to hold her legs and arms in place, fearing she would hurt herself. It looks like she’s using every bit of power left in her to oppose me.

But why so suddenly? Even though the aphrodisiac should be at its peak strength as Emily tells me.

While still thrashing, Lily’s mouth opens again…

“Noooo….just this….don’t…..just this…”

I feel myself getting more and more nervous as words keep coming out of her mouth. The girl I love is telling me to stop raping her. Though I cannot tell, as her eyes are blindfolded, but her voice sounds like she is crying. I cannot take this much longer. I need to finish this fast.

“P-Please I beg you…..just this….only him….” She begs, her voice louder than before.

Lily really is sobbing now. Her voice is quivery and shaky. Any signs of aphrodisiac that was showing till now completely gone.

And what does she mean by only him? Who’s she talking about?

“P-Please….only he can…..only him…. No one else…”—Lily’s voice turns into a whisper again—“…only…

“Caiden….”

I stop moving. My mind froze. My whole body feels like lead. I cannot think. I cannot speak. This whole room, Emily, Lily, everything disappeared from my eyes. It feels like I am drowning into a great ocean. Slowly drifting apart into its depth, like in a dream.

“Caiden….”

Suddenly a voice brought me back; Lily’s voice. I found myself hugging her tightly. Tears streaming down my cheeks.

Why? Why am I crying?

Lily is sobbing hard too, but for an entirely different reason. She keeps repeating my name saying, only him and only he can.

“Caiden”—this time Emily’s voice came—” you know that this is the only way, right?”

Even Emily sounds a bit sad.

I am going to save you, Lily, please bear with me. Thinking that in my mind I grab hold of her hands and locked her thighs with mine.

“NOOO….PLEASE…PLEEEASE..” Lily yells

But I did not stop this time. I move my dick to line up with her pussy and slowly thrust it in. Her pussy is so wet from before that my huge penis slide in somehow, though it still feels incredibly tight.

After an inch or two a feel my penis hitting some sort of obstruction. This must be Lily’s hymen; her proof of virginity, her purity. I am going to break it apart and become her first and only man.

“NOOO….JUST THIS….I WILL DO ANYTHING ELSE…..JUST THIS….” Lily screamed while begging.

Paying her no heed, I put a bit force on my hips and with a faintest tearing sound my penis makes its way inside Lily’s pussy; it’s clenching my dick way too tightly.

I stay in this position waiting for Lily’s scream of pain but it never came. Lily is surprisingly quiet. Even the clench I was feeling from her pussy loosens. I lift my upper body a little, away from the hugging position we were in to take a look at her.

Her face is expressionless. I cannot see her eyes but her mouth, from which she had been yelling moments ago is closed shut.

It looks like something else other than her hymen broke inside my Lily.